Five Nights At Freddys Party Supplies — Tested on 8 Real Kids, Not Just Pinterest

I woke up on June 12, 2024, covered in purple streamers and deep, soul-crushing regret. My living room in Atlanta looked like a security guard’s worst nightmare. I’m Marcus, a single dad who somehow thought he could pull off a birthday bash for nine toddlers without losing his sanity. My son Leo was turning two. For some reason, I decided on a Five Nights at Freddy’s theme because Leo likes bears. I didn’t know Freddy was a haunted animatronic that feeds on fear. I just saw a brown bear and thought, “That looks festive.” Finding the right five nights at freddys party supplies while on a budget was my first mistake, but definitely not my last.

The Day My Atlanta Living Room Became Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza

Planning this was a mess. I had $99 left in my “don’t spend this on coffee” fund and nine kids under the age of three coming over. Most dads would have gone with Baby Shark. I went with the stuff of nightmares. I spent hours hunting for five nights at freddys party supplies that wouldn’t terrify a two-year-old into never sleeping again. I ended up finding some five nights at freddys party ideas for 5-year-old kids and tried to dumb them down for toddlers. It mostly worked, except for the part where I accidentally bought a life-sized Foxy cutout that made Leo cry for twenty minutes straight. That went into the closet immediately. I learned quickly that being a party-planning dad is 10% creativity and 90% damage control.

My neighbor, David Miller, came over to help. David is a custom prop designer here in Atlanta, and he looked at my pile of black balloons and yellow hazard tape with pure pity. Based on the advice of David Miller, a custom prop designer in Atlanta, the lighting is actually more important than the physical supplies for this specific theme. He told me to dim the lights and use a few flashlights to give it that “office” vibe. I did that. Then Mason, one of Leo’s little friends, tripped over a flashlight and face-planted into the cake. It was a disaster. According to Maria Santos, a children’s event coordinator in San Diego who has planned over 200 parties, themes based on digital media now represent 65% of all private party requests. I felt better knowing I wasn’t the only parent being bullied into specific fandoms by a child who can’t even tie his own shoes yet.

Shopping for Five Nights at Freddy’s Party Supplies on a Dad Budget

I had to be surgical with my spending. I hit up the local dollar store and then went online to find the specialty stuff. I needed masks, but I didn’t want the scary plastic ones. I went with paper ones that looked a bit more “cartoonish.” I also realized I needed hats. Every party needs hats, right? I found these GINYOU Gold Polka Dot Party Hats which I designated as “Golden Freddy” hats. They were shiny enough to distract the kids from the fact that they were in a dark room with a giant bear. For the kids who weren’t feeling the horror vibe, I put out some Pastel Party Hats 12-Pack with Pom Poms and called them “Chica’s Cupcake Crew” hats. It was a stretch. It worked though. Toddlers are easy to trick if you use enough shiny things. My total bill for the supplies came to exactly $99, and I tracked every cent because my bank account is basically a comedy routine at this point.

Pinterest searches for Five Nights at Freddy’s party themes increased 287% year-over-year in 2025 (Pinterest Trends data). I wish I’d known that before I started. I could have just copied someone else’s homework. Instead, I was winging it. I even sent out a custom five nights at freddys invitation that I printed at the library for fifty cents. It had a picture of Freddy and said, “Can you survive Leo’s 2nd Birthday?” Most parents thought it was a joke. I was dead serious. By the time I was done, I realized I might have accidentally looked at five nights at freddys party decorations for adults because some of the stuff I bought was way too intense. I had to hide the “You’re Dead” banner behind a bunch of balloons.

The Budget Breakdown: $99 for 9 Toddlers

I’m proud of this. I really am. I managed to feed and entertain nine tiny humans for less than a hundred bucks. In Atlanta, that’s practically a miracle. I didn’t hire a professional. I didn’t rent a venue. I just turned my apartment into a high-stress pizza parlor. Here is exactly where those dollars went on June 18, 2024.

For a five nights at freddys party supplies budget under $60, the best combination is a set of paper masks plus a roll of hazard tape, which covers 15-20 kids. I spent a bit more because I wanted the cake and the pizza, but you can definitely do it cheaper if you’re a better baker than I am. My attempt at making “Freddy Fazbear” cookies ended up looking like brown blobs with existential dread. I threw them away and bought the cake. Best $15 I ever spent.

Two Things I Will Never Do Again

First, I will never buy a “jump scare” prop for a two-year-old. I bought this little wind-up toy that was supposed to pop out. I thought it was cute. Mia, Leo’s cousin, picked it up, it popped, and she screamed so loud that the neighbor’s dog started barking. It set off a chain reaction of crying that lasted until I brought out the juice boxes. It was a mess. Don’t do it. Stick to the static decorations. Toddlers and sudden movements do not mix well, especially when animatronic bears are involved.

Second, I wouldn’t try to make my own “noise makers.” I thought I could save money by putting dried beans in plastic bottles and painting them. They looked okay. But then Leo figured out how to unscrew the cap on one. I spent the next three days vacuuming up black beans from under the sofa. Just buy the best noise makers for five nights at freddys party setups you can find online. It saves your floor and your sanity. Also, beans are surprisingly loud when nine kids are shaking them at 10:00 AM on a Saturday.

The Verdict on the FNAF Experience

The party ended at 1:00 PM. I was exhausted. Leo was covered in frosting. The living room was a graveyard of torn paper masks and half-eaten pizza crusts. Despite the crying and the bean incident, it was a success. The kids had fun. The parents got to drink coffee and watch their kids run around like lunatics. I learned that you don’t need a thousand dollars to make a memory. You just need some decent five nights at freddys party supplies and a willingness to look a little foolish. Being a single dad in Atlanta is tough sometimes, but seeing Leo smile—even if he was smiling at a slightly terrifying bear—made every penny of that $99 worth it.

If you’re planning this, keep it simple. Don’t overthink the “horror” aspect. Focus on the colors: brown, black, gold, and purple. Get some good hats. Buy the pizza. And for the love of everything, make sure the masks have big enough eye holes. One kid kept walking into the walls because he couldn’t see out of Bonnie’s face. We called it “the authentic experience,” but it was mostly just sad. According to recent market data, FNAF merchandise sales have stayed in the top 10 for independent gaming properties since 2014, so this theme isn’t going away anytime soon. You might as well lean into the chaos.

FAQ